10 Costly Short-Term Rental Mistakes (and How to Avoid Them)
Running a short-term rental in Indianapolis can be a fantastic investment. Guests love our city for games, conventions, hospital stays, and those “wait, Indy is actually cool?” weekend trips. But here’s the part nobody puts on the Instagram highlight reel: a handful of short-term rental mistakes can quietly drain your revenue, ding your reviews, and turn a fun side hustle into a full-time headache.
We’ve been managing boutique STR and MTR homes around Indy since 2022 at Brentwood Property Group, and we’ve seen the same tripwires over and over. Some are funny in hindsight. Some are expensive. All of them are avoidable.
Here are ten costly short-term rental mistakes—and how to dodge them like a local who knows which downtown exits to skip during a Pacers game.
1. Skipping Indianapolis permits and local rules
This is the big one, and it is not the fun kind of big.
Indianapolis now requires an annual short-term rental permit for each unit through the city’s Short-Term Rental Permit Program (in effect since January 1, 2025). According to the City of Indianapolis landlord and short-term rental registries page, the initial permit carries a one-time $150 fee, renewals are free, and the rental must be in a legally built dwelling that meets building code requirements.
Skipping registration is not a “we’ll deal with it later” situation. It is a compliance risk, a listing risk, and a stress risk. HOA rules and condo bylaws can also restrict or ban STRs even when the city says you are clear—so read those documents before you buy the mid-century sofa of your dreams.
How to avoid it: Confirm city permitting, neighborhood rules, and any HOA/condo restrictions before you list. If you partner with a local manager, make sure permitting and documentation are part of the onboarding checklist—not a sticky note you find six months later.
2. Assuming platform insurance is enough
Airbnb and similar platforms offer host protections, but those programs have limits, exclusions, and fine print that could fill a novella. Investopedia’s overview of Airbnb host liabilities walks through risks like guest injuries, neighboring property damage, legal compliance, and tax obligations—and why relying only on a platform’s coverage can leave gaps.
Your standard homeowners policy often excludes commercial short-term rental activity. That surprise is never the fun kind.
How to avoid it: Talk to an insurance pro who understands STRs. Ask specifically about liability, property damage, loss of income, and whether mid-term stays change anything. Keep proof of coverage with your property docs.
3. Treating pricing like a set-it-and-forget-it Crock-Pot
A flat nightly rate all year is one of the most common short-term rental mistakes we see in Indianapolis. Indy demand swings with conventions, sporting events, graduation weekends, holiday travel, and quiet midweeks when the city takes a nap.
Static pricing means you undercharge on hot dates and sit empty on soft ones. Either way, you leave money on the table—or worse, you attract the wrong guest with a “too good to be true” rate.
How to avoid it: Use dynamic pricing that reacts to seasonality, lead time, local events, and competitor availability. Review performance weekly, not “whenever we remember.”

4. Listing with phone-photo energy
Guests decide with their eyes first. Dark, cluttered, or oddly angled photos tell them the stay might feel the same. A gorgeous home with mediocre photos will lose to an average home with excellent photos. That is not fair. It is still true.
How to avoid it: Hire a photographer who understands hospitality listings. Shoot in daylight. Declutter like you are about to host your pickiest relative. Highlight the moments guests care about: the primary bed, the shower pressure vibes, the workspace, the parking, the backyard.
5. Writing listings that say everything and nothing
“Cozy! Convenient! Great location!” Congratulations—you have described every listing on the internet.
Vague copy creates mismatched expectations. Mismatched expectations create one-star novels in your review section.
How to avoid it: Be specific. How many minutes to Gainbridge Fieldhouse? Is parking in a driveway, garage, or street? Is the “office nook” a real desk or a vibes-only corner? Spell out house rules, quiet hours, and what is actually included. Clarity converts—and it protects your reviews.
6. Underestimating turnover and cleaning standards
In short-term rentals, cleaning is not a chore. It is the product.
A rushed turnover shows up as hair in the drain, a half-empty soap bottle, or sheets that smell like “someone else’s weekend.” Guests notice. Reviews notice louder.
How to avoid it: Use a detailed checklist, quality control photos, backup cleaners, and enough turnover time between stays. Stock consumables before they hit empty. If you are managing yourself, schedule cleaning like a non-negotiable appointment—not a hope.

7. Slow (or chaotic) guest communication
Nothing says “we are winging this” like a three-hour reply to “How do I get in?”
Guests book STRs for convenience. Delayed answers, conflicting instructions, or “did you check the second PDF?” energy creates anxiety before they even unlock the door.
How to avoid it: Use templates for the common questions, but keep them human. Offer clear check-in steps, Wi-Fi details, parking notes, and an after-hours path for true emergencies. Aim to respond quickly—especially around arrival windows.
8. Ignoring mid-term rental demand
Indianapolis has strong demand for stays longer than a weekend: traveling nurses, corporate assignees, relocating families, and people who need a soft landing between homes. If you only chase one-night weekend bookings, you may be working harder for less predictability.
How to avoid it: Build a strategy that can flex between short-term and mid-term stays. MTRs can reduce turnover costs and smooth seasonality when weekend demand softens. The right mix depends on your property, location, and goals—not a one-size-fits-all rule.
9. Skipping maintenance until something dramatic happens
The water heater does not care about your occupancy calendar. Neither does the HVAC when temperatures swing. Deferred maintenance turns into emergency maintenance, and emergency maintenance turns into canceled stays and refund requests.
How to avoid it: Schedule seasonal HVAC checks, test smoke/CO detectors, watch for slow drains, and fix small issues before guests become your unpaid inspectors. Track every repair. Future you will say thank you.

10. Trying to DIY everything forever
Self-managing can work at first. Then life happens: a day job, a family trip, a cleaner who quits on a Friday, a guest who needs help at 11 p.m., and a pricing update you meant to do three weekends ago.
The costliest short-term rental mistake is often invisible: opportunity cost. Time spent firefighting is time not spent on better investments, better rest, or literally anything more fun than resetting a smart lock from a grocery store parking lot.
How to avoid it: Be honest about your bandwidth. If the property is an investment, treat operations like an investment too. A boutique Indianapolis short-term rental management partner can handle guest messaging, cleanings, pricing, and the 2 a.m. “the Wi-Fi name has a typo” texts so you can be the owner again—not the on-call concierge.
What great Indianapolis STR management looks like
Avoiding these mistakes is less about perfection and more about systems:
- Compliance first (permits, taxes, HOA rules)
- Insurance that matches how you actually rent
- Dynamic pricing tied to Indy demand
- Photos and copy that set true expectations
- Cleaning and maintenance that protect reviews
- Communication that feels calm and local
- A strategy that includes short-term and mid-term opportunities
That is the playbook we use at Brentwood Property Group for owners who want strong guest experiences without living inside the inbox.
Ready for a free rental analysis?
If you own a home in the Indianapolis area and want a clear-eyed look at STR/MTR potential—or you are tired of expensive lessons—reach out to Brentwood Property Group for a free rental analysis and management consultation. We are a local, family-run team (Gabe and KiKi Chase), and we keep our portfolio boutique on purpose: fewer homes, better attention.
Your property should feel like a win. Not a second full-time job with worse hours.
FAQ: Short-term rental mistakes in Indianapolis
Do I need a permit to run an Airbnb in Indianapolis?
Yes. Indianapolis requires an annual short-term rental permit for each unit through the city’s Short-Term Rental Permit Program. Review current requirements on the official city registries page before you list.
What is the most expensive short-term rental mistake owners make?
Compliance and insurance gaps tend to be the scariest, because they can create legal and financial exposure. On the revenue side, weak pricing and inconsistent operations quietly cost owners month after month.
Is Indianapolis good for short-term and mid-term rentals?
Indy benefits from events, healthcare travel, corporate travel, and relocating guests. Performance still depends on location, setup, pricing, and management quality—so run the numbers for your specific property.
Should I self-manage or hire Indianapolis short-term rental management?
If you enjoy operations and have reliable local backup, self-managing can work. If guest messages, turnovers, and pricing updates are crowding your life, professional Airbnb management in Indianapolis can protect both revenue and sanity.
How do I get started with Brentwood Property Group?
Visit brentwoodpropertygroup.com and request a free rental analysis. We will talk through your goals, property details, and whether boutique STR/MTR management is the right fit.