Indiana Property Tax Caps for Rental Investors: How I Underwrite Taxes on an Indianapolis Deal (2026)
If you buy rentals in Indianapolis, property taxes are one of the biggest line items you can actually predict. They’re also one of the easiest to get wrong, usually by copying the seller’s tax bill straight into your spreadsheet.
So let’s fix that. Here’s how the Indiana property tax caps work, why your rental gets the 2% cap instead of 1%, what the 2025 reform (SEA 1) changed on 2026 bills, and how I underwrite taxes when I’m helping a client buy in Marion County.
Quick housekeeping: everything below is current as of November 2026 and linked to the official source. Tax rules change, and every parcel is different, so verify your specific property with the Marion County Auditor, Assessor, or Treasurer, or with a tax pro, before you rely on it. I’m a REALTOR, not your CPA.
What the Indiana property tax caps actually are
Indiana’s caps live in the state Constitution, Article 10, Section 1. It limits a taxpayer’s property tax liability to a percentage of the property’s gross assessed value: 1% for property used as the owner’s principal place of residence, 2% for “other residential property” and agricultural land, and 3% for other real property and most personal property.
The Department of Local Government Finance (DLGF) calls these “circuit breaker” credits. Per the DLGF circuit breaker fact sheet, if your tax liability after other deductions and credits is higher than the cap, the county auditor gives you a credit for the difference. Hoosiers voted the caps into the Constitution in November 2010.
| Property type (as of Nov. 2026) | Cap (% of gross assessed value) | What that usually means for investors |
|---|---|---|
| Homestead (your principal residence, with the homestead deduction) | 1% | Your own home, including the unit you live in if you house hack |
| Residential property (not a homestead) | 2% | Single-family rentals, buildings with 2+ dwelling units, second homes |
| Agricultural land | 2% | Rare for city rental buyers |
| Long-term care property | 2% | Not typical for small investors |
| Nonresidential real property and personal property | 3% | Commercial buildings, plus business personal property |
Two things trip people up:
- A cap is a ceiling, not a bill. Per DLGF Tax Bill 101, your bill is your net assessed value times your local tax rate, minus credits. The cap only kicks in if that number is higher. Local budgets still set the rate.
- Referendum taxes sit outside the caps. The Constitution says voter-approved referendum taxes don’t count toward the limits, and DLGF explains that the bill shows them as an “adjustment” in Table 2 of your tax statement (Tax Bill 101).

Why your rental is taxed at the 2% cap, not 1%
The 1% cap is reserved for homesteads. DLGF’s fact sheet is blunt about it: a property must receive the homestead standard deduction to get the 1% cap (fact sheet). And the homestead deduction only goes to an individual’s principal place of residence.
Meanwhile, DLGF defines “residential property” to include a single-family dwelling that isn’t part of a homestead, and any building with two or more dwelling units. That’s your classic rental, duplex, or small multifamily, and it’s the 2% bucket. The Constitution’s own definition of “other residential property” is property used for residential purposes that isn’t someone’s principal residence, which is why I also underwrite second homes and typical STR and midterm houses at 2%.
A wrinkle for short-term rental buyers
DLGF’s definition of residential property specifically excludes real property that consists of a commercial hotel, motel, inn, tourist camp, or tourist cabin (fact sheet). If you’re buying something that operates more like a lodging business than a house, ask the assessor how it’s classified before you assume 2%.
(If you’re buying an STR or MTR and want help running the numbers, our team at Brentwood manages short-term and midterm rentals, and I help investors buy long-term, short-term, and midterm rentals and flips.)
What SEA 1 (2025 reform) changed on 2026 tax bills
The Marion County Treasurer calls Senate Enrolled Act 1 of 2025 one of the most substantial updates to Indiana’s property tax structure in decades. The changes started on 2025 Pay 2026 bills and keep rolling out for several years. Here’s what matters to a rental buyer, per DLGF’s deductions and credits overview and DLGF’s May 27, 2026 memo:
- A new deduction for 2% properties. Non-homestead residential property (your rentals) gets an automatic deduction off assessed value: 6% for 2025 Pay 2026, then 12% for 2026 Pay 2027, 19% for Pay 2028, 25% for Pay 2029, 30% for Pay 2030, and 33.4% for 2030 Pay 2031 and after. No application needed; the auditor applies it.
- The homestead standard deduction is now a flat amount that phases out. It’s $48,000 for the 2025 assessment date (Pay 2026), then $40,000, $30,000, $20,000, $10,000, and $0 for the 2030 assessment date and after.
- The supplemental homestead deduction grows. It’s 40% of the remaining assessed value for taxes payable in 2026, rising to 46% (2027), 52% (2028), 57% (2029), 62% (2030), and 66.7% (2031 and after).
- A new supplemental homestead credit. Starting with taxes payable in 2026, homestead owners get a credit equal to the lesser of $300 or 10% of the year’s tax liability. Rentals don’t get it.
Good news for investors, but it doesn’t close the gap between an owner-occupied bill and a rental bill.
How I underwrite property taxes on an Indianapolis deal
When I underwrite a rental purchase for my clients, I treat the seller’s tax bill as a clue, not an answer.
Step 1: Check whether the seller’s bill is homestead-capped
Pull the parcel’s current bill from the Marion County Treasurer and look at the deductions table (Table 5 on the TS-1 statement, per DLGF). You can also check homestead status with the Auditor’s deduction search. If you see homestead deductions, that bill reflects the 1% cap and owner-occupant deductions. You won’t get either as a landlord.
Step 2: Re-run the math as a rental
Here’s a hypothetical illustration with round numbers, not a real property, using only the official deduction amounts and cap percentages above. Say a house has a gross assessed value of $200,000 for a Pay 2026 bill:
| Hypothetical $200,000 gross AV (Pay 2026) | Seller lives there (homestead) | You own it as a rental |
|---|---|---|
| Homestead standard deduction | −$48,000 | — |
| Supplemental homestead deduction (40% of remainder) | −$60,800 | — |
| New 2% property deduction (6% of AV) | — | −$12,000 |
| Net assessed value (what the rate is applied to) | $91,200 | $188,000 |
| Circuit breaker cap | 1% = $2,000 | 2% = $4,000 |
| Supplemental homestead credit | Lesser of $300 or 10% of liability | None |
Same house, same assessment: the taxable value and the ceiling both roughly double as a rental. That’s why copying the seller’s bill makes deals look better than they are.

Step 3: Apply the local rate, then compare to the cap
Your actual tax is net assessed value times the local rate for that parcel’s taxing district (Line 3a and Table 3 on the bill, per Tax Bill 101), minus credits. Then compare that to 2% of gross assessed value, plus any referendum adjustment shown in Table 2. You’ll owe whichever is lower. Rates vary by taxing district, so I don’t use a citywide average.
Step 4: Don’t assume the assessment stays put
Per DLGF, assessed values are adjusted every year, up or down, to reflect market value-in-use (fact sheet). So in my own underwriting I stress-test taxes using the purchase price as a stand-in for gross assessed value. If the deal still works at a 2% ceiling on what you paid (plus any referendum add-on), you’re not counting on a lucky assessment.
Want to plug in your own numbers? Try our Indianapolis investment calculator, then tell me what you’re looking for and I’ll help you pressure-test it.
Step 5: Remember Indiana taxes are paid in arrears
DLGF labels tax years like “2025 Pay 2026,” meaning the 2025 assessment is billed and paid in 2026 (DLGF). So the deductions, and any homestead the seller had, can carry into the bill you pay after closing. Ask your title company how taxes are being prorated on your deal.
House hackers: you get the 1% cap, with strings attached
If you live in the property as your principal residence, you can apply for the homestead deduction, and that’s what unlocks the 1% cap. (New to the idea? Here’s my guide to house hacking Indianapolis.)
- Apply on time. In Marion County, an application completed by January 15 shows up on that year’s bill. For example, applying by January 15, 2026 is reflected on the spring 2026 bill (Marion County Auditor). DLGF notes you can file Form HC-10 with the auditor or use the Sales Disclosure Form at closing (DLGF).
- Ask how a multi-unit parcel is split. The homestead covers your dwelling. If you live in one unit and rent the others, ask the assessor how the parcel is divided between homestead and residential classes.
- Tell the auditor when you move out. You must notify the county auditor within 60 days of becoming ineligible, for example when the property changes use. Under HEA 1210 (effective July 1, 2026), someone who doesn’t notify and keeps claiming the deduction shall owe the extra taxes plus a 10% civil penalty (DLGF memo, May 27, 2026).
Thinking about a duplex or a first rental? Tell me what you’re looking for and I’ll help you underwrite the taxes the right way.

Assessments and appeals: the basics
If you think your assessment is off, the Marion County Assessor handles two types of appeals:
- Subjective appeals cover opinion-based issues like grade, condition, or market adjustment. The Marion County Assessor lists the deadline as June 15 of the payable tax billing year (indy.gov).
- Objective appeals cover data errors, like the wrong square footage or a fireplace you don’t have. Marion County gives you three years to file these (indy.gov).
Statewide, appeals start with Form 130. If the Form 11 assessment notice is mailed before May 1 of the assessment year, the deadline is June 15 of that year; if it’s mailed on or after May 1, it’s June 15 of the year the tax statements are mailed. Evidence can include an appraisal or comparable sales, and an appeal can raise, lower, or keep the assessment the same.
Payment due dates and late penalties
Indiana property taxes are paid in two installments. For 2026, Marion County’s due dates were May 11, 2026 and November 10, 2026 (Marion County Treasurer; also confirmed by DLGF). If you pay within 30 days after a due date (and don’t owe back taxes on that property), the penalty is 5% of the unpaid tax. After that, it’s 10%.
Ready to find a deal that still pencils at a 2% tax cap? Tell me what you’re looking for and I’ll start the search. You can also read more about how I help Indianapolis investors buy or my roundup of the best ways to invest in Indianapolis real estate.
FAQ: Indiana property tax caps for investors
What are the Indiana property tax caps?
As of November 2026, Indiana’s Constitution caps property taxes at 1% of gross assessed value for homesteads, 2% for other residential property and agricultural land, and 3% for other real property and most personal property (Art. 10, Sec. 1). Voter-approved referendum taxes sit outside the caps.
Is my rental property capped at 1% or 2%?
A rental that isn’t your principal residence doesn’t get the homestead deduction, so it falls under the 2% cap for residential property (DLGF). Only a homestead gets 1%.
Does SEA 1 lower taxes on rentals?
It adds an automatic deduction for 2% properties: 6% of assessed value for Pay 2026, rising to 33.4% for Pay 2031 and after (DLGF). Your bill still depends on your assessment and local rates.
Can I get the homestead deduction on a duplex I live in?
You can apply for the homestead deduction on your principal residence (Marion County Auditor). If you rent out other units, ask the assessor how the parcel is split between classes.
When are Marion County property taxes due?
Twice a year. The 2026 due dates were May 11 and November 10, 2026 (Marion County Treasurer). Check the Treasurer’s site for upcoming dates.
How do I appeal my assessment in Indianapolis?
File Form 130 with the Marion County Assessor. Subjective appeals are due June 15 of the payable tax billing year (indy.gov).
This guide is general information as of November 2026, not tax or legal advice. Property tax laws change often. Verify the details for your parcel with the Marion County Auditor, Assessor, or Treasurer, or with a qualified tax professional.